Showing posts with label The Situation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Situation. Show all posts

Friday, December 2, 2011

The Situation

In the November eNews, we asked: What would you do?

The weather is perfect, the dirt is tacky and you've driven far up into the mountains and camped get an early start on an epic bike ride with your crew. After hearing the proposed route you use your smart phone to double check the planner's itinerary. You learn that due to recent user conflicts there is an 'advisory' on a section of the route that asks that bikers should ride on even days only. Today is an odd day. What do you do?

A few responses:

Spend the day checking the bikes, get a training ride in, explore the mountains and shred the trail even earlier the next day. Minimize impact. Also, it is advised. Try a different route.
-Summer Pearson

Determine if there is sufficient information to resolve the conflict by timing, walking the specific section, or a reroute around the conflicted section. If none of these are a solution, I would look for a new route in the general area.
-John Konyn

Let us know what you would do.

Wednesday, August 31, 2011

Your Responses to August's "Situation"


Thank you for responding to the last “Situation” in August’s eNews.

The Situation: You are taking a group of kids on their first camping trip. All summer, they've been excited about sitting around a campfire, telling ghost stories and having s'mores. As you're packing the car, you check the website one last time and learn that a campfire ban has been announced for the area you are visiting. What will you do as an alternative so that the kids have a memorable first camping experience?

How Agata and Jason Ketteridge from the Leave No Trace Staff responded:

To many, the tradition of the campfire is an integral part of enjoying the comraderie of any camping trip. Fires, however, have compromised the natural appearance of many recreational areas and are not always necessary to having a memorable first camping trip. There are many things you can do as a substitute to having a campfire:
-If the group you are camping with is very excited about having s’mores, then try roasting marshmallows over your campstove (it works!).
-When there is a fire going, people tend to forget to look up and check out the sky. Schedule some star-gazing time and everyone will be amazed and impressed. You can even download an application on your smartphone that will help you and your group identify constellations.
-Create the ambiance of a fire by putting a light into your colored Nalgene bottle or be creative and design your own luminaries.
-And don’t forget the instant classic “shadow puppet” theatre!


How you responded:

With a campfire ban I would get a bunch on candles to cook the marshmallows — perhaps one with a fat base, or a votive in something. Then put the assembly on a solid level surface on something that will not burn (diameter three times the height of the candle).
-Jay M. Dement

Having a "camp-fire" during a fire ban is fairly easy to accomplish. Any number of small battery operated lanterns can be set at varying heights in a "fire ring". You can also use those small battery powered lights which look like votive candles and intersperse them among some small branches to make it look more fire-like. S'mores can be made ahead of time in the oven by wrapping the graham crackers, marshmallows and chocolate in aluminum foil and baking them in the oven. To re-heat, use a camp stove and griddle.
-Paula Snellgrove

We always have a backup plan for campfire. We lite several candle lanterns or use our burner. This gives us the glow of the fire and allows us to safely control the surroundings. The troop has just as much fun, leaves no damage to the environment, and maintains the fire ban.
-Angela Watts

Tuesday, August 9, 2011

The Situation for July

In last month’s newsletter, we asked:
On your way down from a short, out-and-back hike to a popular historic outlook, something catches your eye. Stranded crackers, chips and a twist-tie are left on a picnic-perfect granite slab where earlier you noticed some college students snacking. Thinking that you could definitely recognize the party who was eating there, and that you could easily catch up to them, what would you do?

This is what you said:
Leftover crackers, chips, twist ties? And I’m pretty sure I know who left them on the rock? And I think I could catch up with them? I’d pick them up, hike down to catch up with the group, and politely tell them that they forgot something…the dialogue would be something like: “Excuse me. Are these yours? I saw you sitting on the rock where I found these. I’m sure you didn’t intentionally leave them behind, because you’re probably aware these leftovers and wrappings may not be great for the environment. Nevertheless, if you don’t want them back, I’d be happy to toss them. Enjoy the rest of your hike!”
-Liz Fitzgerald

If the group is not in earshot of the party, the food is abandoned. Collect all of it as either food for yourself or trash. Since the route is short, it is more likely trash to me. I would not make any attempt to catch up with the group and would proceed according to my own hike plan.
-John Blocher

Given the situation the first thing I would do is take a picture then pack out the trash. Assuming that I would run into the offenders, and I was sure it was them, I would approach them and start talking about how nice the day is and how great a place we are fortunate to have and visit. Hopefully this would start some friendly conversation. Then I would turn the conversation to conservation, “You know how important it is that people don’t deface this wonderful area” and “how would you feel if you went to some nice spot and found it had been trashed and violated. ”Assuming, there were following my thoughts I would then announce “You will not believe what I just found back on the rocks” and with this I would show the garbage I found. I would tell them I found the rock crying and the animals scared because of the trash. And, how happy they were when I picked everything up. I would assume that these people did not know they were doing something wrong and that I could show them how this behavior is not consistent with the good type of people they are.
-Jay Dement

I’ve done something similar in situations similar but not exactly the same. I would probably collect the stuff, then when I caught up with them I would be all perky and dumb and say something like, “OMG! I’m so glad I caught up with y’all! Y’all dropped all this stuff accidentally and I know you didn’t mean to leave it! You might need it!!” As I was saying that, I’d push the stuff into their hands. (People usually tend to reach out to take something if you hand it to them.) Since I’m old enough that I’d probably remind them of their mom, it usually works. The “dumb mom” act can defuse any defensive mechanism that might kick in on the part of the kids. If they reacted well, I might even go a step farther and give them a VERY brief Leave No Trace spiel. If they got defensive anyway, I would just leave, taking whatever stuff they didn’t take with me. Worth a try, anyway...
-Sandra Sallee

Crackers chips twist tie and students. First gotta pack it out. If I were able to catch them I would confront return and explain a little Leave No Trace. Assuming they were caught up with the beauty of the area and were absent minded the Leave No Trace information presented would serve as a lesson for their next outing. If not able to catch them proper disposal and I still feel good.
-John C. Cary

“What I would do first is clean up the mess. Leaving it behind may give others the impression that's it's okay to leave things like that behind. If you can then catch up to the suspect group, ask them if they left the debris behind. If the answer is no, thank them for leaving no trace. If the answer is yes, tell them you cleaned up the mess, and offer to dispose of it, or offer it to them so they may dispose of it. In any case, be polite and friendly, and ask that they practice Leave No Trace in the future, and offer suggestions on how that may be done. For example: Carry their supplies out in a plastic or paper bag thay can be used as a trash bag at clean up time.”
-Dan West

The Leave No Trace e-tour responds:
Engaging in conversations with fellow outdoor users can often be a sensitive issue for both parties. Being familiar with a technique called the “ Authority of the Resource” is a solid approach to entering into a friendly constructive dialogue with other outdoor users who might be engaging in actions considered to be less than Leave No Trace. This particular scenario was a true-life experience, and I’ll respond by recounting the resolution.

I gathered up the litter and crumbs in a baggie that had come from my own snacks. At a point where the group had to pause to allow safe passage over some slippery granite, I opened the conversation with a friendly hello, and a comment about how even the short hike had made me hungry. Mentioning that I had seen them consuming some tasty snacks, I remarked that I was looking forward to my lunch back at the car. Now knowing that I had engaged the correct group of users, we had a conversation on how animals might become ill from eating human food, as we might if we ate the animals’ food. I explained the idea of the litter as a social impact from a visitor’s perspective instead of the simple “feeding the birds” which was the intent of their actions. When I showed the group the litter I had collected, not only did they apologize for me having to do so, but offered me a granola bar to stave off my grumbling stomach.

For Dr. Wallace’s work go to: http://carhart.wilderness.net/docs/manuals/waappg.pdf

Monday, July 4, 2011

Comments on the Use of Trekking Poles

A few comments on the use of trekking poles from the Leave No Trace Center for Outdoor Ethics’ June eNews.

Rather than when to use, I'd like to address the equipment itself. The golfing industry went through a similar dilemma related to shoe spikes. Everyone knew the sharp metal spikes damaged the greens (and the clubhouses). After years of working to improve the product, metal spikes were ultimately completely replaced by less scarring plastic and complete replacement of the single-long spike in favor of a smaller, multi-pronged approach.

Couldn't Leave No Trace and its members have more of an impact by both working on guidelines for pole use and on pole spike design and composition? You need both, as the single spike pole design is not likely to change quickly. Why not have a contest to develop the best composite, "single spike replacement" design? Since it would be plastic, it will wear out and likely need to be replaceable. Perhaps poles could have a number of interchangeable nibs (to borrow some fountain pen terminology) for various terrain. Just a thought.
Patrick Koontz,
Leave No Trace Trainer



Most of the trails here consist of soils with high clay content. Hiking on them when they are soft does considerable damage. The public should refrain from hiking on soft muddy trails until they have a chance to dry out and firm up.
Larry Ames,
Interpretive Specialist for the Bureau of Land Management in Ukiah, CA


Baskets for your trekking poles can prevent the large divot holes made by poles that do not have baskets. As the poles are planted, the basket keeps the poles from sinking into the mud as you stay on the designated trail! Consider using the baskets that your poles came with.
Lindy Spiezer,
Formerly with trekking pole manufacturer Leki USA

Thursday, January 27, 2011

The Situation


In last December’s eNews, we posed the following question in a new column called The Situation:

While camping with some friends, you notice someone in the next campsite trying to burn food scraps in their campfire. What would you do?

Aaron Diving, Aaron Divine, M.S. who is a lecturer in Parks and Recreation Management in the Department of Geography, Planning, and Recreation at Northern Arizona University sent in this great response:

I was intrigued by the situation as we often have similar discussions on many of the Leave No Trace Master Educator courses that we teach here at Northern Arizona University. A few thoughts to the proposed situation entailing next door campers burning food scraps, etc. in the campfire - for starters, this is a highly situational scenario.

The first question I would ask myself, as I normally do in such cases, is "How strong are my personal convictions in this specific setting or with this particular issue? Am I strongly attached to a certain outcome or position along the ranging spectrum or not?" I suppose, the more personal conviction I have tied to a potentially divisive issue, the more important it is for me to take the necessary time to cool down and consciously analyze my thoughts in an attempt to avoid creating an uncomfortable or even potentially volatile encounter with someone who I do not know but am ultimately trying to befriend and educate on the positive elements of Leave No Trace.

Next steps would be dependent on whether or not I have already established a positive connection with these individuals. If the answer is Yes, then I would probably be more compelled to engage in a friendly discussion with them about the issue. If the answer is No, then I would not likely make my first encounter with them seem as though I were the Leave No Trace police" and watching their every move.

As I got to know the individuals I would garner a feel for how to best approach the topic with my new neighbors - I hope there would be a whole host of ways to bridge the gap - without sounding condescending or preachy. It may be most appropriate to simply begin by raising awareness of the basic cause/effect of such actions and leave it at that. And, depending on their interest in the subject, prolong or curtail the ensuing conversation accordingly.