Showing posts with label burning trash. Show all posts
Showing posts with label burning trash. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

March Situation Response

The Situation

You are car camping at a park and have read the regulations, which clearly state that there is no disposal of greywater on the ground. Unfortunately, there is no literature telling what you should do otherwise. What would you do?


What you said:

A few options...
1. Drink it. If it's a solo outing, there shouldn't be much of it anyway.
2."Pack it out." If it's car camping, then chances are I've got a container I can dedicate to holding the greywater till I leave the campground.
3. Flush it? If there are flush toilets, and it's not prohibited, is there any harm in letting the septic system sort it out?

-Nathan Hicks


Ask the ranger what to do with your greywater if you don't know what to do with it. Every park has different facilities...some might have a drum to collect it and it is hauled away like Farragut in Idaho, or a sink that goes into a sanitary sewer like some of the state parks in PA. Don't put it in the outhouse unless specifically told to do so.

-Marj Eby



The no-grey-water-on-the-ground rule means that there won't be any soap, even biodegradable, involved with the solar shower, probably no solar shower use at all. Washing dishes will require straining, and hopefully sumping, the wash and rinse water. Hopefully the park has sumps or a disposal station. Lacking that means using really damp paper towels for washing and rinsing and then sealing those up in large zip locks for the trip to the garbage can.

-Brent Baum



If you're car camping then there are probably bathrooms or pit toilets nearby. I would dispose of the water there.
If not, then I would check with local officials if possible for direction. If not possible, I would broadcast the water as widely as possible.

-Matthew Flitton



There has to be an area for human waste like a washroom facility or outhouse. Many areas will pump out waste to remove it in the situation of an outhouse I personally would dump my grey water in a place like that, thus it is not in the ground where it could harm plant life or attract unwanted animals, second option would be to strain or filter any large particles out of the grey water and could use remaining water for putting out camp fires or be dumped in a cat hole

-Tim Lane


I am assuming by "grey water" you mean the water from washing dishes, pots, pans, etc... In that case it is sumping time! Mmmmmm! Add hot water to your pots, pans, bowl, etc.... mix and stir well and then down the hatch it goes! Of course you can strain out the chunks to pack them out and then sump the liquids.

-Art Woodard



What our traveling trainers, Mark and Tara, said:


Ask the management or rangers at the park . If you have an appropriate container you can capture it and dispose of it at the dump station if the park has one. If you have strained out all particulates and set them aside for the garbage or compost, you can ask the park about flushing it down the toilet. If you cannot get an answer from the staff, do what you think is best. Leave No Trace is about how to minimize our unavoidable impacts, and the solution is not always easy to find.


To learn more about burning trash or adding food scraps to your campfire please read Skills in the April eNews.

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

What's In Your Campfire?

While most people familiar with Leave No Trace generally do not burn trash, those who are uninformed occasionally (or perhaps more often) burn trash in their campfire. While this seemingly innocent act may not cause seemingly significant immediate impacts, there are impacts nonetheless. As with most recreation-related impacts, damage done to the environment is cumulative over time, and in the case of campfires it leads to fire rings full of partially burned trash and food waste that are often very attractive to wildlife. This then leads to other problems. For example, wildlife can become attracted and conditioned to human food and trash and seek out these items, often to their own detriment. Although these kinds of campfire related impact occur over time, there are much more acute campfire impacts from burning trash.

In 2004 the USDA Missoula Technology and Development Center, a USDA Forest Service research facility, studied the toxins released from various kinds of trash when burned in a campfire. The researchers burned everything from plastic bags to batteries to baby diapers. Over 27 different items were burned, and both the gas emissions and ash content were analyzed. The results were scary at best. Numerous chemicals, most of which are known carcinogens, were released from the burning trash. Lead, xylene and benzene were just a few of the many toxins released from burning trash.

Interestingly enough, the study showed that even campfires that just burn wood released a significant amount of air pollutants. The addition of garbage greatly increased the pollutants and toxins released. Ash left over from a fire that contained only wood primarily consisted of nontoxic elements. However, when garbage was burned, toxic compounds in the ash were greatly increased. As a result, the researchers recommend that anyone handling campfire ash wear protective gloves. Furthermore, they recommended that all trash, regardless of what it is, be packed out and properly disposed of in a trash receptacle.


To view the full study, visit: http://air.ky.gov/SiteCollectionDocuments/WhatsBurninginYourCampfire_Article.pdf

Thursday, January 27, 2011

The Situation


In last December’s eNews, we posed the following question in a new column called The Situation:

While camping with some friends, you notice someone in the next campsite trying to burn food scraps in their campfire. What would you do?

Aaron Diving, Aaron Divine, M.S. who is a lecturer in Parks and Recreation Management in the Department of Geography, Planning, and Recreation at Northern Arizona University sent in this great response:

I was intrigued by the situation as we often have similar discussions on many of the Leave No Trace Master Educator courses that we teach here at Northern Arizona University. A few thoughts to the proposed situation entailing next door campers burning food scraps, etc. in the campfire - for starters, this is a highly situational scenario.

The first question I would ask myself, as I normally do in such cases, is "How strong are my personal convictions in this specific setting or with this particular issue? Am I strongly attached to a certain outcome or position along the ranging spectrum or not?" I suppose, the more personal conviction I have tied to a potentially divisive issue, the more important it is for me to take the necessary time to cool down and consciously analyze my thoughts in an attempt to avoid creating an uncomfortable or even potentially volatile encounter with someone who I do not know but am ultimately trying to befriend and educate on the positive elements of Leave No Trace.

Next steps would be dependent on whether or not I have already established a positive connection with these individuals. If the answer is Yes, then I would probably be more compelled to engage in a friendly discussion with them about the issue. If the answer is No, then I would not likely make my first encounter with them seem as though I were the Leave No Trace police" and watching their every move.

As I got to know the individuals I would garner a feel for how to best approach the topic with my new neighbors - I hope there would be a whole host of ways to bridge the gap - without sounding condescending or preachy. It may be most appropriate to simply begin by raising awareness of the basic cause/effect of such actions and leave it at that. And, depending on their interest in the subject, prolong or curtail the ensuing conversation accordingly.

Monday, December 20, 2010

Burning Trash



Thanks to all of you who posted comments on our recent Facebook question: Is it ever OK to burn trash in your campfire? Why or why not?


How many of us have seen a trashed fire ring? Trash begets trash. It's just a fact. Ideally, all trash should be packed out, every time, everywhere. Burning trash is generally not acceptable under any circumstances. Even paper products, while combustible, don't always burn completely and can lead to flying embers. Another item that shouldn't be burned is food. It generally takes a hot fire to fully combust foods, and leftover food scraps are a strong attractant to wildlife.

Another issue is the toxins released from burning different items. The Missoula Technology and Development Center (MTDC), a USDA Forest Service research facility, released a study in 2004 on campfire toxins which can be viewed here: http://www.fs.fed.us/t-d/pubs/htmlpubs/htm04712833/index.php

For more research on campfire impacts, visit: http://www.springerlink.com/content/m533171002750054/

For your next campfire, keep the following in mind:

• Ask about pertinent regulations and campfire management techniques.
• Judge the wind, weather, location, and wood availability. Decide whether it’s safe and responsible to build a campfire.
• Where there are no fire rings or grates, bring a fire pan or set aside time to build a mound fire.
• Have a trowel or small shovel and a container for saturating the ashes with water.
• Never leave a fire unattended.
• Don’t try to burn foil-lined packets, leftover food, or other garbage that would have to be removed later.
• Burn the wood completely to ash: Stop feeding the fire, and give yourself an hour or more to add all the unburned stick ends.
• Saturate the ash with water. Make sure it’s cool to the touch, and remove any trash.
• Scatter all the ashes widely with a small shovel or pot lid.
• Restore the appearance of the fire site.